The Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability

Speaking Up For You employed 6 Advocates to support people to tell their story in the Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability (Disability Royal Commission). SUFY acknowledges the Disability Royal Commission advocates, Nance Haxton, Linda McKey, Rikki Chaplin, Kerryann Harman-Schufft, Christie Groves and Deanne Gibbs and thanks them for their dedication and invaluable work.

The Disability Royal Commission was established in April 2019 in response to community concern about widespread reports of violence, abuse, neglect and exploitation of people with disability. SUFY conducted 17 Information Sessions across Brisbane and Moreton Bay to spread the word about the Disability Royal Commission. Between November 2019 and June 2023, SUFY engaged with 280 people and informed them about the Disability Royal Commission. SUFY assisted 109 people to make a submission to the Disability Royal Commission and 34 people to take part in private sessions with the Disability Royal Commission. SUFY Advocates, staff and Management Committee either personally contributed to or made their own submission to the Disability Royal Commission, totalling 10 systemic submissions, 4 private sessions and 1 SUFY Disability Royal Commission Advocate provided evidence.

After receiving 7,944 submissions, conducting 1,785 private sessions and 33 public hearings the Final Report was published on 29 September 2023 and includes 222 recommendations. These recommendations focussed on changes to laws, policies, structures and practices that affect people living with disability, their family and carers, advocates and service providers.

How many of the 222 recommendations has the Federal Government agreed to?

Devastatingly, the Federal Government only agreed to 13 (approximately 6%) of the recommendations in full (https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/disability-rights-groups-devastated-by-governments-royal-commission-response/zgxv490j3) and accepted 117 in principle. A further 42 recommendations were either noted or are being considered. The Federal Government considered that State and Territory governments are primarily responsible for 50 of the recommendations.

It is notable that, as at the end of 2024, there have been 140 Commonwealth Royal Commissions. From other Royal Commissions, such as the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody, it has been seen governments change their mind over time, acting on recommendations at times and then ignoring them.

Because of the importance of the Disability Royal Commission and its recommendations, advocates at Speaking Up For You will remind governments at all levels, of specific relevant recommendations. In doing so, Speaking Up For You pays respect to and honours the many people with disability (almost 10,000) who engaged in the Royal Commission at great emotional cost, in the hope that their lived experience would generate positive change. Speaking Up For You, as a member of the Queensland Independent Disability Advocacy Network (QIDAN) supports the ‘DRC Still Matters Campaign’. This campaign tracks:

  • What governments have committed to.
  • What has been implemented.
  • What is in progress.
  • Where there has been little or no change.

Information on the DRC Still Matters Campaign can be found at: https://qidan.org.au/thedrcstillmatters/

While all the 222 recommendations are important (and can be found from p. 193 of the Final report – Executive Summary, Our vision for an inclusive Australia and Recommendations.docx), we mention some of them below. The terminology for the government responses include:

  • Accept means the government agrees or supports the recommendation;
  • Accept in Principle means the government agrees with or supports the overarching policy intent in the recommendation but may consider different approaches to its implementation.
  • subject to further consideration, meaning the government is still thinking about the

recommendation; and

–     note or noted, means the government views it as inappropriate to indicate acceptance or rejection, possibly because the recommendation is not within its responsibility. In most of these cases it will say it is the States/Territories responsibility.

 

Some of the recommendations include:

  • Enact a Disability Rights Act (Recommendations 4.1 to 4.21) in consultation with people with disability, disability representative organisations and other key stakeholders. The Disability Rights Act will incorporate the international human rights set out in the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), so that they become enforceable in Australian law. The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendations are subject to further consideration.
  • Establish a National Disability Commission (Recommendations 4.18 and 5.5) to monitor and oversee the Disability Rights Act, hold capacity-building functions, including research, publishing guidelines, providing advice, handling complaints, and intervening in certain court proceedings. It would also have the power to address non-compliance with the Disability Rights Act, using inquiries, enforceable undertakings, compliance notices, and injunctions, provide information, dispute resolution, and referrals to police and other oversight bodies. The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendations are subject to further consideration.
  • Strengthening disability rights protection in state and territory laws (Recommendation 4.22) – the States and territories should enact legislation complementary or equivalent to the Australian Disability Rights Act, taking into account their own legal frameworks. The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendations are subject to further consideration. The Queensland Government responded that it will modernise and strengthen Queensland’s anti-discrimination legislation by implementing a staged approach to the recommendations made by the Queensland Human Rights Commission in its report Building Belonging – Review of Queensland’s Anti-Discrimination Act 1991.
  • Amendments to the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), including that when a person (alleged discriminator) who treats, or proposes to treat, the person who says they have been discriminated against, unfavourably, has the burden of proving that the treatment or proposed treatment was not on the ground of the person’s disability (Recommendation 4.23). This and other related recommendations were accepted in principle by the Federal Government.
  • The Australian Government and state and territory governments should, before the end of 2024, develop a new National Disability Agreement through the Disability Reform Ministerial Council, to be signed by first ministers. The fundamental objective of the Agreement should be to advance equality, inclusion and the rights of people with disability in Australia. The Agreement should provide the framework for intergovernmental collaboration to: develop and implement reforms requiring national attention and coordination, including Royal Commission recommendations; implement Australia’s Disability Strategy 2021–2031 (ADS) and the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) (Recommendation 5.1) The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendations are subject to further consideration, while Queensland and the other States and Territories accepted the recommendation in principle.
  • By the end of 2024, establish: a dedicated ministerial portfolio for disability and carers policies and programs; a ministerial position: the Minister for Disability Inclusion – responsible for disability inclusion strategy, policies and programs; and a Department of Disability Equality and Inclusion dedicated to improving outcomes for people with disability, with responsibility for the national disability and carers policies and programs that are currently sitting with the Department of Social Services (Recommendation 5.6). The Federal Government and the Queensland Government noted the recommendation.
  • The Australian Government and state and territory governments should have a designated focal point for matters relating to implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (Recommendation 5.7). The Federal Government, Queensland and the other States and Territories, all accepted the recommendation in principle.
  • The Australian Government and state and territory governments should, by the end of 2024, develop and agree on an Associated Plan (to be co-designed) in connection with Australia’s Disability Strategy 2021–2031 to improve the accessibility of information and communications for people with disability (Recommendation 6.1). The Federal Government, Queensland and the other States and Territories, all accepted the recommendation in principle.
  • The Australian Government and state and territory governments should increase the number of Auslan interpreters (Recommendation 6.2) and the Australian Government, through the National Accreditation Authority for Translators and Interpreters (NAATI) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) should take steps to ensure people with disability have access to appropriately skilled and qualified interpreters as needed (Recommendation 6.3). The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendations are accepted in principle.
  • States and territories should review and amend their guardianship and administration legislation so it is consistent with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, recognising and promoting the rights of people with disability (Recommendation 6.5), and includes supported decision-making principles (Recommendation 6.6), enables appointment of supporters (Recommendation 6.7) and representation orders be made only as a last resort (Recommendation 6.8). The Queensland Government’s (along with the Australian Capital Territory, Northern Territory, Tasmania, and Victoria) response was that the recommendations are accepted in principle.
  • State and Territory Public Trustees should publish accessible information about the services they provide to people under administration orders, the fees and charges applicable for those services and the ways in which fees are calculated for each person (Recommendation 6.17). The Queensland Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted in principle.
  • For the financial years 2024–25 and 2025–26, the Australian Government should commit additional funding of: $16.6 million per annum for the National Disability Advocacy Program; and $20.3 million per annum for the National Disability Insurance Scheme Appeals Program. After this time these amounts should be indexed to maintain their value in real terms from year to year (Recommendation 6.21). The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted in principle.
  • The Disability Advocacy Work Plan associated with the 2023–2025 National Disability Advocacy Framework should be amended to include priority work areas on increasing culturally appropriate and accessible advocacy services for people with disability from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds and LGBTIQA+ people with disability (Recommendation 6.23). The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted in principle.
  • Build the capability of the health workforce by the Australian Government Department of Health and Aged Care by immediately expanding the scope of the work on an intellectual disability health capability framework and associated resources to address all forms of cognitive disability, to apply at all stages of education and training. This expansion should include autism-specific content, and address specific healthcare issues for people with learning disability, dementia and acquired brain injury (Recommendation 6.25). The Federal Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted in principle.
  • Providing for inclusive education (Recommendations 7.1 to 7.15) the Federal Government’s response was to accept in principle most of the recommendations, while noting the recommendation to phase out segregated schooling and the alternate recommendation to include interconnection between students at non-mainstream and mainstream schools.
  • In relation to employment (Recommendations 7.16 to 7.32) the Federal Government accepted recommendations 7.16 and 7.17, stating that the design of the new specialist disability employment program addresses key elements proposed in this recommendation, along with recommendations 7.27 – enable a Fair Work Ombudsman referral mechanism; 7.28 – improve information about wages and the Disability Support Pension for Australian Disability Enterprises employees in particular; 7.29 – embed an ‘open employment first’ approach in the NDIS Participant Employment Strategy and for the remaining recommendations, either noted, accepted in principle or along with State and Territory governments, stated that they were subject to further consideration.
  • In relation to housing (Recommendations 7.33 to 7.44), the Federal Government accepted Recommendation 7.34 to include homelessness in Australia’s Disability Strategy and in relation to the other recommendations, either accepted in principle or along with State and Territory governments, stated that they were subject to further consideration.
  • State and territory governments should uphold the rights of people with disability who are in custody, including provision of the disability supports they require to place them in the same position, so far as feasible, as other people in custody (as required under article 14 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities) (Recommendation 8.1). The Queensland Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted in principle.
  • State and territory governments should work with First Nations child protection services, peak bodies and First Nations people with disability to co-design clear principles and guidelines for parenting capacity assessments for First Nations parents with disability in their jurisdiction, to ensure assessments are culturally appropriate (Recommendations 9.1). The Queensland Government’s response was that the recommendation is accepted.
  • The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) should provide block funding for First Nations Community Controlled Organisations to flexibly deliver supports and services to First Nations people with disability (Recommendation 9.5). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • Section 127 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) should be amended to provide that the National Disability Insurance Agency Board must include at least one First Nations person at all times (Recommendation 9.6). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA), the First Nations Advisory Council and First Nations Community Controlled Organisations should co-design policy guidelines on funding for First Nations family members to provide supports to participants in remote communities (Recommendation 9.9). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • The Australian Government and state and territory governments should support the establishment of a First Nations Disability Forum to lead further development and implementation of the Disability Sector Strengthening Plan (DSSP) by the end of March 2024. The Forum should consist of:
        • First Peoples Disability Network
        • First Nations Community Controlled Organisations
        • both Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peak bodies
        • First Nations people with disability (Recommendation 9.10).

The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.

  • The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission (NDIS Commission) should commission a capacity-building program to support disability service providers to embed human rights in the design and delivery of their services. The program should be co-designed with people with disability, disabled people’s organisations, disability representative organisations including member-led First Nations Community Controlled Organisations, and peak bodies (Recommendation 10.1). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission should co-design – with people with disability, disabled people’s organisations, disability representative organisations including member-led First Nations Community Controlled Organisations, and peak bodies – a practice guide on supported decision-making for service providers (Recommendation 10.7). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • The Australian Government should establish a national disability support worker registration scheme by 1 July 2028 (Recommendation 10.8). The Federal Government stated that recommendation was subject to further consideration.
  • The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission (NDIS Commission) should establish a dedicated intelligence unit within the NDIS Commission to enhance its capacity to collect intelligence, identify and respond to higher risk participants, take action relating to providers where necessary and identify systemic issues (Recommendation 10.27). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.
  • The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission should establish a dedicated First Nations Unit to develop its engagement with and understanding of the issues facing First Nations participants in the National Disability Insurance Scheme, particularly in regional and remote communities (Recommendation 10.29). The Federal Government accepted in principle the recommendation.

 

For more information, you can visit the Disability Royal Commission website by clicking here.

To read the Final Report, click here.

Scroll to Top
Skip to content